Book Review: Philosophy 101, by Paul Kleinman

Philosophy 101: From Plato and Socrates to Ethics and Metaphysics, an Essential Primer on the History of Thought, by Paul Kleinman (Adams Media, 2013). My rating: 5 of 5.

You took a philosophy class once, or you meant to. Now you keep running into names like Hume, Kant and Kierkegaard, and arguments that start with a runaway trolley. You do not need a graduate seminar. You need a short, friendly map. That is what this book is.

What the book covers

Kleinman’s primer runs about 290 pages and moves in short entries, each one a thinker, an idea or a famous puzzle. He opens with the six big fields of philosophy: metaphysics, logic, epistemology, aesthetics, politics and ethics. Then he covers the Greeks, the medieval thinkers, the early moderns, existentialism and modern logic, with thought experiments mixed in. He avoids jargon, and the entries are short enough to read one at a time.

What stayed with me

Arguments on paper. Kleinman lays arguments out as numbered premises and a conclusion. When an argument in something I am drafting feels slippery, I write it out that way. A missing or weak premise shows up fast. The three classic laws of thought, identity, noncontradiction and excluded middle, make a quick check for any brief or letter.

The Socratic method. His description of a law professor questioning a student about a judge’s reasoning is exactly how law school works. It is a good way to explain to a non-lawyer how lawyers think.

Ethics and purpose. Aristotle and Aquinas get fair, clear treatment. Kleinman sums up Aristotle’s view that “the purpose of ethics is to discover the purpose of life,” and that virtue is the path to happiness. Aquinas’s four cardinal virtues, justice, prudence, courage and temperance, still hold up.

The commons. The prisoner’s dilemma and the tragedy of the commons show, as Kleinman puts it, that “pursuing one’s own self-interest and gratification will actually turn out to be self-defeating in the long run.” That applies to partnerships, families and shared property.

The ship of Theseus. If every plank of a ship is replaced, is it the same ship? I think about that one with businesses after a buyout and with trusts amended over decades.

Bacon’s idols. Francis Bacon’s four sources of false thinking work as a checklist for bias in your own reasoning. The idol of the marketplace, confusion caused by loose words, matters most for anyone who writes for a living.

A few notes

A primer simplifies, and a few points need care. Rousseau’s famous line is usually translated “Man is born free, and everywhere he is in chains.” Use a standard translation. The doctrine of double effect starts with Aquinas, but its four formal conditions came from later moral theologians in the 1800s. Kant’s objection to the ontological argument is that existence is not a real predicate, which the book does not state clearly. And if you cite logical positivism, note that its own verification rule cannot be verified, one reason it fell apart.

Who should read it

Curious adults, students before a first philosophy course, and professionals who want sharper tools for argument. Read it as a map, then pick up the original thinkers who catch your interest.

Quotes are short excerpts credited to the author. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. The price you pay does not change. I read this book on my own, and no one asked me or paid me to review it. See Disclosures.