Book Review: You Have the Right to Remain Innocent, by James J. Duane

You Have the Right to Remain Innocent, by James J. Duane (Little A, 2016). My rating: 5 of 5.

You have done nothing wrong. An officer, or a federal agent, asks if you would mind answering a few questions. You want to be helpful, and you have nothing to hide, so you start talking. Duane, a law professor, wrote this short book to explain why that instinct can hurt an innocent person, and why the Constitution gives you the right to stay quiet.

What the book covers

The book grew out of a widely viewed lecture Duane gave to law students. In about 150 pages he walks through how statements to police are used in court, why helpful parts of what you said usually stay out while harmful parts come in, how honest mistakes get treated as lies, and how mistaken but confident witnesses can sink an innocent defendant.

He also covers what to say, and what not to say, when you decide not to talk. You do not need legal training to follow it.

What stayed with me

The rules of evidence cut one way. Duane explains that “a prosecutor is allowed to handpick the parts of your statement to the police that might be used against you”. Your own helpful statements are usually hearsay when you try to offer them. Most people have never heard this, and it changes how you think about a friendly conversation.

Honest errors look like lies. If you misremember a time or a place, the other side can argue you lied on purpose. Duane shows how that one inference can damage a defense in several ways at once.

Why innocent people talk anyway. People keep making the same mistake “because they think they have nothing to hide”, and because they want to seem cooperative.

The present tense versus the past. In a street encounter, Duane separates questions about who you are and what you are doing right now from questions about where you were earlier.

The tax side of the same lesson. I read this as a tax lawyer. When an IRS special agent from Criminal Investigation calls, the same logic applies. Making a false statement to a federal agent is its own crime under 18 U.S.C. section 1001, so a nervous, inaccurate answer can create a new problem that did not exist before.

A few notes

Courts have tightened the rules since the cases many people remember. The Supreme Court has held that an unclear request for a lawyer does not count (Davis v. United States, 1994), that simply staying silent does not invoke the right to silence (Berghuis v. Thompkins, 2010), and that silence before arrest and before warnings can be used against a person who never expressly invoked the Fifth Amendment (Salinas v. Texas, 2013). Clear words matter.

Washington has no general stop and identify statute, but drivers must show a license when an officer asks (RCW 46.20.017), and giving false identification is never a good idea. The book also repeats the claim that the average American commits about three felonies a day. That figure comes from Harvey Silverglate’s book of that name and is an illustration, not a measured statistic.

I do not practice criminal defense. If you are facing a criminal matter, talk with a criminal defense lawyer licensed where you are.

Who should read it

Anyone who has ever thought, I have nothing to hide, so why not talk. Parents of teenagers, business owners, and anyone who may someday get a call from a government agent should read it.

Quotes are short excerpts credited to the author. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. The price you pay does not change. I read this book on my own, and no one asked me or paid me to review it. This review is general education, not legal or tax advice. Laws change, and the right answer depends on your facts. Legal services are offered only through Centerbridge Law Group, PLLC, 1610 Commercial Avenue, Suite 203, Anacortes, Washington 98221. See Disclosures.